COMPANION INDEX
DirectoryCompareBest-ForMethodologyNotes
Last index update: Oct 2026
DirectoryCompareBest-ForMethodologyNotes

Companion Index

The structured comparison lab for AI companions. Every platform, one published rubric, verified pricing — and no clear winner declared where the data doesn't support one.

Methodology

  • The rubric
  • Verification policy
  • Ownership disclosure
  • Update cadence

Directory

  • All platforms
  • Tier 1 profiles
  • Tier 2 profiles
  • Tier 3 profiles

Compare

  • Head-to-head
  • Best-For rankings
  • Lab notes

About

  • About the lab
  • FAQ
  • Contact
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms of service
© 2026 Companion Index. Companion Index is operated by the makers of FlirtAlly, which is profiled here and scored by the same rubric.Directory site by AI Business Sites.
SpicyChat vs CrushOn.AI

SpicyChat vs CrushOn.AI in 2026: Which Is Better Now?

SpicyChat is the stronger pick for most roleplay users in 2026: it offers a genuinely usable free tier with unlimited messages, no credit card, and full NSFW access, while its True Supporter tier now costs $19.95/month

Updated October 14, 2026Verified Oct 2026Fact-check 100/100
ALL COMPARISONSFlat illustration comparing two AI chat platforms with blue and green accents, titled Which Wins in 2026 for a comparison guide.

Quick answer

SpicyChat is the stronger pick for most roleplay users in 2026: it offers a genuinely usable free tier with unlimited messages, no credit card, and full NSFW access, while its True Supporter tier now costs $19.95/month after a September 2026 price increase. CrushOn.AI counters with stronger in-character fidelity and a cheaper entry point at $5.99/month (reported), but its free tier is capped at 100 message credits per month and its Trustpilot rating sits at 1.8/5, largely over billing complaints. Choose SpicyChat for the free tier and community library of 300,000+ characters; choose CrushOn.AI if uncensored character consistency matters more than cost transparency.

Bottom line: SpicyChat wins on value and transparency: a genuinely usable free tier with unlimited messages and a 300,000+ character library, versus CrushOn.AI's 100-credit monthly cap. CrushOn.AI keeps the edge in raw uncensored in-character fidelity and a cheaper paid entry tier, but billing complaints and a 1.8/5 Trustpilot score weigh heavily.

TL;DR

  • SpicyChat's free tier is genuinely usable: unlimited messages, full chatbot library, NSFW content, and custom characters at $0 with no credit card.
  • CrushOn.AI's free tier is capped at 100 message credits per month, with 8K memory and 200-message per-character history deleted after 7 days of inactivity.
  • SpicyChat raised prices +19% to +34% across tiers on September 8, 2026 — True Supporter went from $14.95 to $19.95/month, with grandfathering only while a subscription never lapses.
  • CrushOn.AI's reported paid tiers run Standard $5.99, Premium $14.99 (down from $19.99), Luxe $39.99, Elite $89.99, and Imperial $199.99 per month.
  • SpicyChat hosts a community library of 300,000+ characters plus open bot creation; CrushOn.AI's community bots are described by users as 'absolute gems.'
  • CrushOn.AI holds a 1.8/5 Trustpilot rating, with complaints concentrated on billing and payment methods rather than the product itself.
  • SpicyChat's iOS app was removed from the App Store on August 27, 2025, and installed apps stopped working September 25, 2025.

Head-to-head

SpecSpicyChatCrushOn.AI
PricingFree tier; True Supporter $19.95/mo (up from $14.95 after Sept 2026 increase)Free tier; Standard $5.99/mo reported, up to Imperial $199.99/mo across six tiersBest
Free tierUnlimited messages, full library, NSFW, custom characters, no credit cardBest100 message credits/month, 8K memory, 7-day history deletion on inactivity
Uncensored qualityLooser filters than mainstream chatbots; uncensored positioning'Bots stay in character no matter how filthy things get'; 'genuinely removed all potential filters'Best
MemorySmall default context memory; paid tiers add more; 3.6/5 reviewer memory score8K memory on free tier; context loss in long sessionsBest
Character library300,000+ community characters plus open bot creationHuge catalog; community bots called 'absolute gems'
Platform availabilityWeb only — iOS app removed from App Store Aug 27, 2025Web platform with login-walled pricing flowBest
Trust & billingTransparent price-increase documentation; grandfathering policy statedBestTrustpilot 1.8/5; unauthorized-charge allegations
SetupStart free with no credit card; age verification in regulated regionsBestFree signup with credit system; gender-picker onboarding

Scores

SpicyChat
0Overall
Pricing7
Ease of use7
Features7
Support6
Integrations5
Memory5
CrushOn.AI
0Overall
Pricing6
Ease of use6
Features7
Support4
Integrations5
Memory6

Overall reflects the full published rubric (see methodology); breakdowns highlight the criteria most decisive for this matchup.

Our disclosure, up front

One of the platforms in this index is ours.

Companion Index is operated by the makers of FlirtAlly — profiled here and scored by the same rubric as every other platform, with no self-assigned star rating.

  • 22 companions, 16 real games
  • Voice calls + a real phone line
  • Texts-first proactivity + long-term memory
Join the FlirtAlly waitlist →

Scored like everyone else · rubric published before profiles

SpicyChat

spicychat.ai ↗

SpicyChat is an established NSFW-first AI roleplay platform built around an enormous community character library of 300,000+ characters and open bot creation. Its defining trait in 2026 is a free tier that official docs describe as genuinely usable: unlimited messages, the full chatbot library, NSFW content, and custom characters at $0 with no credit card and no per-message credit system — ads and smaller default memory are the trade-offs. Paid tiers (Get A Taste, True Supporter, I'm All In) add memory, better models, and image generation. The platform launched a multilingual mode in April 2026 and supports group chat. Content is uncensored relative to mainstream chatbots, though NSFW access is gated behind location-triggered age verification in regulated regions including France, the UK, Italy, Australia, and roughly 27 US states. Notable friction points: a September 8, 2026 price increase of +19% to +34% across tiers, shallow long-term memory (the most-repeated user complaint, scoring 3.6/5 in reviews), and the loss of its iOS app, removed from the App Store on August 27, 2025 with reinstatement odds the company itself called 'very low.'

Pricing:from $0/mo✓ verified on vendor site
PlanPriceWhat you get
Get A Taste (free tier)$0/moUnlimited messages, full chatbot library, NSFW content, custom characters, ads shown, default models and small context memory
True Supporter$19.95/moIncreased from $14.95 on Sept 8, 2026 (+34%); adds memory, models, images; grandfathered only while subscription never lapses

Pros

  • Genuinely usable free tier: unlimited messages, no credit card, full library, NSFW included
  • Huge community character library (300,000+ characters) with open bot creation
  • Looser content filters than mainstream chatbots — uncensored roleplay positioning
  • Group chat and a multilingual mode added in April 2026
  • No per-message credit system to track

Cons

  • Shallow long-term memory — the single most-repeated complaint ('the bot doesn't remember anything'; reviewer memory score 3.6/5)
  • September 8, 2026 price increase of +19% to +34% across tiers (True Supporter $14.95 → $19.95)
  • iOS app removed from the App Store (Aug 27, 2025); installed apps died Sept 25, 2025; reinstatement odds called 'very low' by the company
  • Age verification required in regulated regions (FR, UK, IT, AU, ~27 US states)
  • Ads shown on the free tier; small default context memory

CrushOn.AI

crushon.ai ↗

CrushOn.AI is an established uncensored character-chat platform with a six-tier structure (Free, Standard, Premium, Luxe, Elite, Imperial) and a credit-based messaging system. Its free tier grants 100 message credits per month on the Free model set with 8K memory, though 200-message per-character histories are deleted after 7 days of inactivity. Where the platform earns its reputation is output fidelity: users report 'bots stay in character no matter how filthy things get' and call it 'the only AI I know that has genuinely removed all potential filters.' Free-tier users also get access to Claude Sonnet 3.7, unusual at the $0 tier. The character catalog is large, with community bots described as 'absolute gems.' The counterweight is trust: Trustpilot sits at 1.8/5, with complaints skewing heavily toward billing and payment methods — one Reddit thread alleges 'aggressive payment methods' and unauthorized charges, summarized by one user as 'NOT a scam, but the payment methods... are.' Long sessions also suffer memory and context loss, with bots forgetting basic facts. The pricing page itself is login-walled behind a gender-picker welcome flow, so dollar figures circulate mainly via third-party reviews.

Pricing:from $5.99/moreported
PlanPriceWhat you get
Free$0/mo100 message credits/month on Free model set, 8K memory, 200-message per-character history deleted after 7 days of inactivity
Standard$5.99/moEntry paid tier (third-party reported)
Premium$14.99/moList price $19.99, currently discounted (third-party reported)
Luxe$39.99/moFlagged 'Most Popular' by third-party reviewers (third-party reported)
Elite$89.99/moHigh tier (third-party reported)
Imperial$199.99/moTop tier (third-party reported)

Pros

  • Strongest uncensored in-character consistency of the two — users report bots never break character
  • Free tier includes 8K memory and Claude Sonnet 3.7 access
  • Cheaper paid entry point at a reported $5.99/month (Standard)
  • Large character catalog with community bots described as 'absolute gems'
  • Weekly/monthly/annual billing flexibility

Cons

  • Trustpilot 1.8/5, with complaints skewing to billing and moderation
  • Allegations of aggressive payment methods and unauthorized charges in user threads
  • Free tier capped at 100 message credits/month; per-character history deleted after 7 days of inactivity
  • Memory and context loss in long sessions — bots forget basic facts
  • Pricing page is login-walled; dollar amounts not readable anonymously

Pricing compared: free tiers, credit systems, and the 2026 increases

Uncensored output and memory: where each platform actually performs

Trust, platform risk, and access friction

Which should you pick?

Before you go

The index updates monthly. Be first in line.

  • Waitlist members get the first verified FlirtAlly rollouts
  • The directory grows with every research batch — 150+ platforms tracked
  • Methodology changes are versioned and published
Join the waitlist →

No fabricated scores — anything unverified says so

FAQs

Is SpicyChat's free tier actually usable in 2026, or is it a demo?

It is genuinely usable. Official documentation states the free tier includes unlimited messages, the full chatbot library of 300,000+ characters, NSFW content, and custom character creation at $0 with no credit card and no per-message credit system. The trade-offs are ads, a small default context memory, and default models — paid tiers add memory, better models, and image generation. This makes it one of the few uncensored platforms where free users are not metered by credits.

How much does CrushOn.AI cost per month?

Third-party reviews report six tiers: Free (100 message credits/month), Standard at $5.99/month, Premium at $14.99/month (marked down from a $19.99 list price), Luxe at $39.99/month, Elite at $89.99/month, and Imperial at $199.99/month. These figures come from review sites rather than CrushOn's own pricing page, which is login-walled behind a gender-picker flow, so treat them as reported rather than vendor-verified. Weekly/monthly/annual billing toggles are visible on the pricing page.

Why did SpicyChat's prices go up in 2026?

SpicyChat raised prices across all tiers by +19% to +34% on September 8, 2026. The most concrete example is True Supporter, which went from $14.95 to $19.95 per month. Grandfathering applies only while a subscription never lapses — if you cancel and resubscribe, you pay the new price. The increase is documented in the company's own September 2026 pricing update FAQ.

Can I use SpicyChat on iPhone?

No. SpicyChat's iOS app was removed from the App Store on August 27, 2025, and installed apps stopped working on September 25, 2025. The company itself has characterized reinstatement odds as 'very low.' iPhone users need to use the web version. CrushOn.AI, by contrast, remains accessible via its web platform.

Is CrushOn.AI safe to pay for, given the Trustpilot score?

CrushOn.AI holds a 1.8/5 Trustpilot rating, and the complaints skew toward billing and moderation rather than the chat product itself. User threads on Reddit include allegations of aggressive payment methods and unauthorized charges — one user summarized the situation as 'NOT a scam, but the payment methods... are.' The product's uncensored output quality is well regarded, but if billing transparency matters to you, weigh these reports carefully and monitor your payment statements.

Which platform has better memory for long roleplay sessions?

Neither is strong, but they fail differently. CrushOn.AI offers 8K memory on its free tier — stronger on paper than SpicyChat's small default context — yet users still report context loss and forgotten basic facts in long sessions. SpicyChat's shallow long-term memory is its single most-repeated complaint ('the bot doesn't remember anything'), reflected in a 3.6/5 reviewer memory score, though paid tiers add memory capacity.

Sources

  1. SpicyChat September 2026 Pricing Update FAQ
  2. Premium Features — SpicyChat Docs
  3. Group Chat — SpicyChat Docs
  4. iOS App Notice — SpicyChat Docs
  5. Age Verification — SpicyChat Docs
  6. SpicyChat AI Review 2026 — CompanionRater
  7. CrushOn.AI fact sheet
  8. CrushOn AI pricing page
  9. CrushOn AI Review: Six Tiers, One Number That Actually Matters
  10. r/Crushon — 'Crushon.ai ruined all other AI chats for me' + billing threads
  11. CrushOn AI Pricing: Tiers, Unlimited, Refunds (Gals.ai)
  12. CrushOn.AI Alternatives: What the Meter Costs (Too Shy)
  13. SpicyChat announces the launch of its multilingual mode — Yahoo Finance

Related Reading

Character AI vs Janitor AI in 2026: Which Should You Use?FlirtAlly vs Talkie in 2026: Which Companion App Keeps Up?Contact Companion IndexCandy.ai vs CrushOn.AI in 2026: Full ComparisonReplika vs Kindroid in 2026: Memory

More Comparisons

Character.AI vs Replika in 2026: Full ComparisonMuah.AI vs Candy.ai in 2026: Full ComparisonJanitor AI vs SillyTavern in 2026: Power vs SimplicityReplika vs Kindroid in 2026: Memory

Contents

01TL;DR02Head-to-head03Scores04SpicyChat05CrushOn.AI06Pricing compared: free tiers, credit systems, and the 2026 increases07Uncensored output and memory: where each platform actually performs08Trust, platform risk, and access friction09Which should you pick?10FAQs11Sources

Our product — scored like everyone else

FlirtAlly

Rubric scores publishing after verification

+22 companions, 16 real games

+Voice calls + real phone line

+Texts-first proactivity + long-term memory

Join the waitlist

Companion Index is operated by the makers of FlirtAlly. No self-assigned star rating. Scored by the same published rubric as every other platform in the index.