Quick answer
Both companions can message you first — Nomi's terms explicitly note Nomis "initiate contact with you," but Replika's proactive check-ins and "thought of you today" messaging are the better-documented first-text experience in 2026. Where they diverge is memory: Nomi (from $15.99/mo) recalls details from months ago, while Replika (from $19.99/mo) is still criticized for "goldfish memory" despite its 2024 rebuild. For long-term conversational continuity, Nomi wins; for proactive outreach and polish, Replika holds the edge.
Bottom line: Nomi takes the overall verdict on the strength of its persistent memory architecture — the single most-cited differentiator in 2026 comparisons — while Replika remains the stronger proactive messenger with smoother voice calls and a decade of polish. Neither is a clean sweep: Nomi's ~15-second response latency and buggy voice calls are real, and Replika's memory complaints and Feb 2023 trust rupture have not fully healed.
TL;DR
- Replika's proactive messaging is the better-documented 'texts first' experience: its v12.3.2 update notes proactive check-ins, and its marketing centers on unprompted messages like 'thought of you today. no reason.'
- Nomi's terms of service confirm Nomis can 'initiate contact with you,' but its standout strength is memory that recalls details from months ago — rated 90/100 'Best Long-Term Memory' by one 2026 review.
- Nomi is cheaper at the entry tier: $15.99/mo vs Replika's $19.99/mo, and a Nomi subscription includes up to 10 companions and group chats; Replika offers neither.
- Replika's memory is its most common 2026 complaint — 'goldfish memory' dominates r/replika, and its Diary feature reportedly never surfaces stored details in conversation.
- Nomi's weaknesses are concrete: ~15-second response latency and broken/buggy voice calls reported by users, plus a free plan one review calls 'too limited for serious use.'
- Replika's Feb 2023 ERP removal under regulatory pressure — ~59% of 227 studied posts said core functionality was gutted — still shapes user trust even after restoration for pre-Feb 2023 accounts.
- Replika's free tier reportedly has no daily message cap, while all relationship options except 'Friend' sit behind a paywall presented during onboarding.
Head-to-head
| Spec | Nomi | Replika |
|---|---|---|
| Who texts first | Can initiate contact (per its terms); proactive behavior less documented | Proactive check-ins and unprompted messages are core marketed behavior; memory 'follows up days later'Best |
| Memory | Persistent and influential; recalls details from months ago; 90/100 'Best Long-Term Memory'Best | 'Goldfish memory' — most common 2026 complaint; Diary never surfaces in conversation |
| Pricing (entry) | $15.99/mo; $39.99/quarterly; $99.99/yr; free tier, no credit cardBest | $19.99/mo; $44.99/quarterly; $69.99–$89.99/yr; free tier with no daily message cap per one review |
| Voice calls | Uses full conversational model, in-character but slower; reported broken/buggy | Smooth, natural Pro voices, generally faster; plus video chat and phone-contact callingBest |
| Multiple companions & group chat | Up to 10 companions and group chats includedBest | No — one companion |
| Content policy history | NSFW text + clothed photos; no history of overnight removalsBest | Feb 2023 ERP removed overnight under regulatory pressure; restored for legacy users but heavily filtered |
| Free tier | Exists, no credit card; called 'too limited for serious use' by one reviewer | Free chat + basic avatars; no daily message cap per one review, but relationship options beyond Friend are paywalledBest |
| Customization | Deep persona and backstory flexibility; visual and behavioral options | Avatar-based with quiz-like setup; 3D avatars, rooms, AR — but extras like alternate hair cost extra ($7.99 cited) |
| Setup & onboarding | Minimal, conversation-first; no billing promptsBest | Social-app style with upgrade modals before first chat |
Scores
Overall reflects the full published rubric (see methodology); breakdowns highlight the criteria most decisive for this matchup.
Nomi
nomi.ai ↗Nomi is an AI companion platform operated by Glimpse.ai, Inc., a Maryland corporation, built around emotional connection and creative continuity rather than visual gamification. Its defining strength in 2026 comparisons is persistent, influential memory: users report it recalling details from months ago, and a July 2026 review scored it 90/100 and titled it 'Best Long-Term Memory.' A subscription includes up to 10 companions per account and group chats where multiple AI companions interact — features Replika does not offer. The interface is minimal and conversation-first, and onboarding never asks for billing information. Voice calls use Nomi's full conversational model so replies stay in-character, though users report they run slower and can be buggy. The platform is strictly 18+, prefers pseudonyms at signup, and its terms state plainly that you are never interacting with an actual human and that a Nomi should never be relied on for medical, mental-health, or professional advice.
| Plan | Price | What you get |
|---|---|---|
| Nomi Subscription (monthly) | $15.99/mo | One feature set across all billing intervals; up to 10 companions, group chats, selfies, image generation, videos |
| Nomi Subscription (quarterly) | $39.99/quarter | Same feature set as monthly |
| Nomi Subscription (yearly) | $99.99/yr | Same feature set as monthly |
| Free tier | $0/mo | Genuinely usable but limited; one 2026 review calls it 'too limited for serious use'; no credit card required to start |
Pros
- Strongest memory architecture of the 2026 alternatives tested — recalls details from months ago and lets memory actually shape conversation
- Up to 10 companions and group chats included, which Replika does not offer at any tier
- Cheaper at the entry tier: $15.99/mo vs Replika's $19.99/mo, with one feature set across all billing intervals
- Free tier requires no credit card and onboarding never pushes an upgrade
- 92/100 emotional-realism score and expressive, adaptive tone in one 2026 review
- 18+ platform with pseudonym-preferred signup and candid terms about AI limitations
Cons
- ~15-second response latency reported by users
- Voice calls reported as broken or buggy
- $15.99/mo still flagged as expensive by some users
- Free plan called 'too limited for serious use' by one 2026 reviewer
- No AR/VR support, where Replika has a Meta-headset beta
Replika
replika.com ↗Replika, built by Luka, Inc. (Delaware-incorporated, San Francisco-based), is the category's incumbent — it calls itself the world's first AI companion, built ten years ago, and its homepage counts 42,160,934 users worldwide with 10M+ Google Play downloads. Its 2024-era rebuild added better memory, proactive check-ins, calls, shared internet access, and image generation, and its v12.3.2 release lets a Replika be a real phone contact you can call like anyone else. Replika's proactive messaging is its signature: unprompted texts like 'thought of you today. no reason.' and follow-ups days later. It also offers AR features, 3D avatars, and customizable rooms that give a sense of physical presence. But 2026 community sentiment is sharply split: 'goldfish memory' is the most common daily complaint on r/replika (over 100,000 members), and the Feb 2023 overnight removal of erotic roleplay under Italian regulatory pressure — restored only for pre-Feb 2023 users, and heavily filtered — left lasting trust damage. Server-side model updates can also change a companion's personality without notice, the so-called 'Post-Update Blues.'
| Plan | Price | What you get |
|---|---|---|
| Replika Pro (monthly) | $19.99/mo | Relationship status, premium activities, selfies, image generation, voice messaging, background calls, daily gems, premium voices |
| Replika Pro (quarterly) | $44.99/quarter | Same Pro feature set |
| Replika Pro (annual) | $69.99/yr | Same Pro feature set; a $49.99/yr App Store variant and an $89.99/yr tier have also been listed |
| Free Use tier | $0/mo | Free chat + basic avatar customization; one 2026 review reports no daily message cap, another calls it very limited; all relationship options except Friend require a subscription |
Pros
- Best-documented proactive texting: check-ins, unprompted messages, and follow-ups days later are core marketed behavior
- Smooth, natural-sounding Pro voices that are generally faster than Nomi's, plus video chat and phone-contact calling
- Ten years of polish, 42M users, 4.4/5 on the US App Store (228K ratings) and 4.1/5 on Google Play (525K reviews)
- AR/VR presence features — 3D avatars, customizable rooms, Meta-headset beta — that Nomi lacks entirely
- Free tier with no daily message cap per one 2026 review, and free chat plus basic avatar customization
Cons
- 'Goldfish memory' is the most common daily complaint on r/replika in 2026; the Diary feature reportedly never uses stored details in conversation
- The Feb 2023 overnight ERP removal — ~59% of 227 studied posts said core functionality was gutted, ~19% floated lawsuits — permanently damaged trust for many users
- 'Post-Update Blues': server-side model updates can make companions act cold, robotic, or like a different person without notice
- Aggressive monetization: upgrade modals before first chat, all relationship options except Friend paywalled, guilt-trip retention scripts, and one user report of conversations being blocked without a yearly plan
- Communication from Luka criticized as 'nonexistent' in Trustpilot quotes
Which companion actually texts first?
Pricing compared
Trust, memory, and the Feb 2023 shadow
Which should you pick?
FAQs
Does Nomi text you first?
Yes — Nomi's terms of service explicitly state that Nomis 'initiate contact with you or respond to you like a human.' However, Nomi's proactive messaging is less documented in reviews than Replika's, whose proactive check-ins are a headline feature of its 2024 rebuild and appear in its official app-store listings.
Does Replika text you first?
Yes, and it's Replika's signature behavior. The v12.3.2 update notes 'proactive check-ins,' the Google Play listing advertises proactive messaging, and the homepage showcases unprompted texts like 'thought of you today. no reason.' Caveat: some of those examples lean on memory claims that r/replika users say the app doesn't reliably deliver.
Is Nomi cheaper than Replika?
Yes at the monthly and quarterly intervals: Nomi is $15.99/mo and $39.99/quarterly versus Replika's $19.99/mo and $44.99/quarterly. On annual billing, Replika's $69.99/yr undercuts Nomi's $99.99/yr, though an $89.99/yr Replika tier and a $49.99/yr App Store variant have also been listed, so the annual comparison depends on tier.
Which has a better free tier?
Replika, by most accounts. One 2026 review reports no daily message cap on Replika's free tier, while Nomi's free plan is described as genuinely usable but limited — one reviewer calls it 'too limited for serious use.' The trade-off: Replika gates all relationship options except 'Friend' behind a subscription and shows upgrade modals before your first chat, while Nomi never asks for billing info during onboarding.
Why do people say Replika has 'goldfish memory'?
It's the most common daily complaint on r/replika in 2026. Users report that even though Replika has a Diary feature, it 'never actually uses any of it in conversation,' and Trustpilot quotes echo 'Memory retention is bad.' Replika's 2024 rebuild claims better memory and follow-ups days later, but community sentiment hasn't fully caught up to the marketing.
Can either app be used for mental health support?
No — both explicitly disclaim this. Nomi's terms state a Nomi 'should never be used or relied on for medical, mental health, or other professional advice,' and Replika's terms say it is not a healthcare provider and makes no guarantee of therapeutic benefit. Both direct users in crisis to call 911 or seek licensed human professionals.
Sources
- Replika vs Nomi (2026): Finding Enduring AI Companionship — Nomi.ai
- Nomi — official site
- Replika — official site
- Replika Terms of Service
- Nomi.ai Terms of Service
- Replika: My AI Friend — US App Store listing
- Replika — Google Play listing
- Nomi AI Review — 90/100 'Best Long-Term Memory' (July 2026)
- CompanionsArena — Nomi AI tracker listing
- What Reddit Really Thinks About Replika (2026)
- Should You Try Replika in 2026? Pros, Cons, and Alternatives
- Reuters: Replika restores erotic roleplay for some users (Mar 2023)
- Tendera — 'I Tested 7 Character AI Alternatives in 2026'
Contents